Kylian Mbappe’s performance in Real Madrid’s 2-1 victory over Eintracht Frankfurt in the UEFA Super Cup has sparked a surprising debate in the Spanish capital. While the French superstar is celebrated for his attacking prowess, it was his defensive contribution—or perceived lack thereof—that dominated headlines the day after the match.
The discussion ignited in the 63rd minute of the game in Helsinki. With Frankfurt’s Ansgar Knauff advancing down the right flank, Mbappe, positioned on the left wing, did not track back to challenge him. Knauff delivered a cross that was ultimately cleared, but the moment did not go unnoticed. Spanish television broadcasts replayed the sequence, highlighting Mbappe’s stationary position as his direct opponent charged forward.
This single incident has divided Madrid’s media. Some outlets have been fiercely critical. A headline in the newspaper Marca bluntly stated, “Mbappe doesn’t defend,” accompanied by images analyzing the play. Similarly, AS ran with “Mbappe’s walk,” criticizing his reluctance to help defensively. The critique centers on a demand for greater commitment and sacrifice, especially in a final where the team needed to secure the result.
However, other prominent voices have rushed to the forward’s defense. Renowned journalist Manu Carreño argued on his program, “Mbappe is not here to defend. He is here to win games.” This sentiment was echoed by former player and analyst Guti during the post-match show on Movistar+. “We cannot ask Mbappe to defend. We have to ask him to do what he does, which is to score goals and win games for us,” Guti stated, emphasizing that the team’s structure should protect its star attacker.
The debate comes after a match where Mbappe, making his official debut for the club, played the full 90 minutes. He provided the assist for Jude Bellingham’s opening goal in the 37th minute and was a constant threat, though he did not find the net himself. The victory secured the first trophy of the 2024/2025 season for Carlo Ancelotti’s side.
This early controversy highlights the intense scrutiny that follows Mbappe. His every move is dissected, and expectations are colossal. While his offensive talent is unquestioned, his role and responsibilities within the team’s tactical framework are already a hot topic in Madrid, setting the stage for a season where his contributions will be analyzed from every possible angle.
